EXTENDING NEW NARRATIVES
  • Home
  • About
    • Project Description
    • Team
    • Postdoctoral Fellows >
      • 2023-24 Post-Doc Ad
    • Governance
    • New Narratives PDG (2015-19)
  • Building Resources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Digital >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliography of Works by Early Modern Women Philosophers
      • Digital Collections
      • Multimedia >
        • Podcast
    • Print
  • Developing Research
    • Conferences
    • Seminars
    • Workshops
    • Works-in-Progress Seminars
    • Reading Groups
    • ENN Blog
    • Other Events
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Media Mentions
    • Publications
  • Related projects
    • Columbia Center for New Narratives in Philosophy
    • In Parenthesis Project
    • Querelle
    • Archeology of the Female Intellectual Identity (AFII)
    • Brazilian Network of Women in Philosophy
    • Center for the History of Women Philosophers and Scientists
    • Histories of philosophy in a Global Perspective
  • Acceuil
  • À Propos
    • Description du projet
    • Chercheurs postdoctoraux, chercheuses postdoctorales >
      • 2023-24 Appel Post-Doc
    • Équipe
    • Direction
  • Construire des ressources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Ressources numériques >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliographie d’œuvres de femmes philosophes du passé
      • Collections numériques
      • Multimédia
    • Ressources papier
  • Développer la recherche
    • Conférences FR
    • Seminars FR
    • Workshops FR
    • Séminaires de travaux en cours
    • Groupes de lecture
    • D'Autres Évènements
  • Nouvelles
    • Annonces
  • Projets liés

ENN Blog

Veronica Franco on Submission and Childbearing as Virtues

11/18/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
​I will first look at Franco’s poem, Capitolo 24. Franco wrote this poem as a response to a man who had insulted and threatened another woman, presumably a fellow courtesan. The entire poem is 160 lines. I will examine lines 70-90 as seen below:
​     And do you want to know what the truth is?              
That the wisest person should be the most patient       
squares with reason and with what is right;                     
     insolence is the mark of the madman,                      
but the stone that the wise man draws from the well        
was thrown in by a foolish, imprudent man.                    
    And so we women, who are wiser than you,              
to avoid contention, carry you on our backs,                  
as the surest of foot carry those prone to fall.                
    But most men do wrong in this matter;                      
and woman, to avoid pursuing wrongdoing,              
adapts and endures being a vassal.                               
    Yet if, as far as reason’s concerned,                           
she wanted to show what she is worth,                      
she’d not only be man’s equal but surpass him by far. 
    But human offspring would cease to exist                 
if woman, determined to prevail in the duel,              
were as harsh and cruel as man deserves.                    
    To not ruin the world, which our species       
makes so beautiful, woman is silent                                       
and submits to tyrannical, wicked man. 

Translation by Anna Rosalind Jones and Margaret F. Rosenthal 
​     E che sia ’l ver, voletelo vedere?
Che ’l piú savio ancor sia piú pazïente
par ch’a la ragion quadri ed al devere:
            del pazzo è proprio l’esser insolente,
ma quel sasso del pozzo il savio tragge,
ch’altri a gettarlo fu vano e imprudente.
            E cosí noi che siam di voi piú sagge,
per non contender vi portamo in spalla,
com’anco chi ha buon piè porta chi cagge.
            Ma la copia degli uomini in ciò falla;
e la donna, perché non segua il male,
s’accomoda e sostien d’esser vassalla.
            Ché se mostrar volesse quanto vale
in quanto a la ragion, de l’uom saría
di gran lunga maggiore, e non che eguale.
            Ma l’umana progenie manchería,
se la donna, ostinata in sul düello,
foss’a l’uom, com’ei merta, acerba e ria.
            Per non gustar il mondo, ch’è sí bello
per la specie di noi, la donna tace,
e si sommette a l’uom tiranno e fello.
Earlier in the poem, Franco argues that virtue lies in the soul and mind and that women “have given/ more than one sign of being greater than men” in this way (65-66). In the excerpt above, Franco outlines the ways in which women show their superiority in virtue. Franco seems to make two arguments here: first, that submission to men serves as an act of virtue and second, that childbearing plays a significant role in both submission and in improving the condition of the world. Through their submission and childbearing, Franco argues, women are superior to men in virtue. 

Franco describes the submission of women as an adaptive response to the weakness of men. Women must guide and carry men because men are weak and prone to “fall” without women’s support. Franco implies that because men “do wrong,” they cannot support the weak in the same way women support men. As a result, women must become the submissive party if they want to “avoid pursuing wrongdoing.” Submission is thus a choice women make in order to compensate for the shortcomings of men. Still, Franco reminds the man whom the poem addresses that, if women were to ignore this call to service and reveal their superiority, women would easily “surpass” men. Yet, a woman intentionally “submits to tyrannical, wicked man” and becomes “silent.” The submission of women, for Franco, acts as both a virtue and a reflection of the strength women have in comparison to men. 

Childbearing, for Franco, exemplifies the virtuous and indispensable submission of women. An end to the submission of women, according to Franco, directly results in an end to childbearing. Franco presents childbearing as a paradigm act of submission. Yet, in providing offspring, women have the unique ability to play a role in improving the condition of the world. For Franco, women bear children so that women do not “ruin the world” and instead, make the world “beautiful.” In this way, submission can be said to empower women as they are able to affect the world in a significant and unique manner by giving birth. For Franco, childbearing embodies the powerful sacrifice women make in order to improve the condition of the world. This submission is also voluntary and actively chosen as a result of the superior reason and morality of women. 

​In the excerpt above, Franco tells the story of why men became the dominate sex. According to Franco, the power of men results directly from the grace and selflessness of women who are wiser and superior in virtue. In order to compensate for the failures of the weaker sex, women submit and support men. The power given to men, however, can be taken back at any time if women refuse to procreate. Yet, their virtuous and reasonable nature leads them to do what is best for the world as a whole and bring the beauty of offspring into the world. The submission of women to men, seen especially in childbearing, exemplifies the virtue and reason of women as they refrain from revealing their true superiority to better serve the world. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    ​Olivia Branscum is a PhD student in Philosophy at Columbia University. She is co-producer of the ENN New Voices podcast

    Haley Brennan is a PhD student in Philosophy at Princeton University. She is co-producer of the ENN New Voices podcast

    ​
    Matheus Mazzochi is an undergraduate Philosophy major at Simon Fraser University. His posts are signed MM.

    Mary Purcell is an MA student at Simon Fraser University. Her posts are signed MP.

    Archives

    December 2022
    October 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021

    Categories

    All
    16th Century Women
    17th Century Women
    18th Century Women
    19th Century Women
    Abolitionism
    Ada Lovelace
    Aesthetics
    Africana Philosophy
    American Women Philosophers
    Andean Philosophy
    Angela Foligno
    Animal Rights
    Anna Julia Cooper
    Anti Oppression
    Anti-oppression
    Anti Slavery
    Arcangela Tarabotti
    Attention
    Audre Lorde
    Beauty
    Black Women Philosophers
    Brazilian Women
    Canadian Women Philosophers
    Catherine Of Siena
    Claudia Jones
    Contemplative Tradtion
    Decolonization
    Early 20th Century Women
    Education
    Edward Blyden
    Emile Du Chatelet
    English Women
    Environmental Ethics
    Equality
    Eternity
    Feminism
    Frances Power Cobbe
    Frederick Douglass
    Free Will
    French Women
    Germaine De Staël
    German Women
    Hadewijch
    Harriet Martineau
    Hildegard Von Bingen
    Idealism
    Identity
    Indigenous Peoples
    Indigenous Philosophy
    Intersectionality
    Italian Women
    Julian Of Norwich
    Karoline Von Günderrode
    Labour Movements
    Language
    Laura Bassi
    Lorraine Hansberry
    Love
    Lucrezia Marinelli
    Margaret Ebner
    Maria Stewart
    Marriage
    Mary Ann Shadd Cary
    Medieval Women
    Metaphysics
    Mind And Body
    Moderata Fonte
    Moral Education
    Natural Philosophy
    Nísia Floresta
    Phenomenology
    Phillis Wheatley
    Philosophy Of Mind
    Philosophy Of Science
    Podcast
    Political Philosophy
    Public Philosophy
    Research Methods
    Rosa Luxemburg
    Sexuality
    Simone De Beauvoir
    Simon Weil
    Sor Juana Inés De La Cruz
    Venetian Women
    Veronica Franco
    Virtue
    W.E.B Du Bois
    Wisdom
    Women's Rights

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • About
    • Project Description
    • Team
    • Postdoctoral Fellows >
      • 2023-24 Post-Doc Ad
    • Governance
    • New Narratives PDG (2015-19)
  • Building Resources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Digital >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliography of Works by Early Modern Women Philosophers
      • Digital Collections
      • Multimedia >
        • Podcast
    • Print
  • Developing Research
    • Conferences
    • Seminars
    • Workshops
    • Works-in-Progress Seminars
    • Reading Groups
    • ENN Blog
    • Other Events
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Media Mentions
    • Publications
  • Related projects
    • Columbia Center for New Narratives in Philosophy
    • In Parenthesis Project
    • Querelle
    • Archeology of the Female Intellectual Identity (AFII)
    • Brazilian Network of Women in Philosophy
    • Center for the History of Women Philosophers and Scientists
    • Histories of philosophy in a Global Perspective
  • Acceuil
  • À Propos
    • Description du projet
    • Chercheurs postdoctoraux, chercheuses postdoctorales >
      • 2023-24 Appel Post-Doc
    • Équipe
    • Direction
  • Construire des ressources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Ressources numériques >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliographie d’œuvres de femmes philosophes du passé
      • Collections numériques
      • Multimédia
    • Ressources papier
  • Développer la recherche
    • Conférences FR
    • Seminars FR
    • Workshops FR
    • Séminaires de travaux en cours
    • Groupes de lecture
    • D'Autres Évènements
  • Nouvelles
    • Annonces
  • Projets liés