EXTENDING NEW NARRATIVES
  • Home
  • About
    • Project Description
    • Team
    • Postdoctoral Fellows >
      • 2023-24 Post-Doc Ad
    • Governance
    • New Narratives PDG (2015-19)
  • Building Resources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Digital >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliography of Works by Early Modern Women Philosophers
      • Digital Collections
      • Multimedia >
        • Podcast
    • Print
  • Developing Research
    • Conferences
    • Seminars
    • Workshops
    • Works-in-Progress Seminars
    • Reading Groups
    • ENN Blog
    • Other Events
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Media Mentions
    • Publications
  • Related projects
    • Columbia Center for New Narratives in Philosophy
    • In Parenthesis Project
    • Querelle
    • Archeology of the Female Intellectual Identity (AFII)
    • Brazilian Network of Women in Philosophy
    • Center for the History of Women Philosophers and Scientists
    • Histories of philosophy in a Global Perspective
  • Acceuil
  • À Propos
    • Description du projet
    • Chercheurs postdoctoraux, chercheuses postdoctorales >
      • 2023-24 Appel Post-Doc
    • Équipe
    • Direction
  • Construire des ressources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Ressources numériques >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliographie d’œuvres de femmes philosophes du passé
      • Collections numériques
      • Multimédia
    • Ressources papier
  • Développer la recherche
    • Conférences FR
    • Workshops FR
    • Séminaires de travaux en cours
    • Groupes de lecture
    • D'Autres Évènements
  • Nouvelles
    • Annonces
  • Projets liés

ENN Blog

Tarrabotti on Education for Women

2/17/2022

0 Comments

 
In “Book Two” of Paternal Tyranny, Tarabotti argues that women should receive an education equal to that of men. She writes:

"Do not scorn the quality of women’s intelligence, you malignant and evil-tongued men! Shut up in their rooms, denied access to books and teachers of any learning whatsoever, or any other grounding in letters, they cannot help being inept in making speeches and foolish in giving advice. Yours is the blame, for in your envy you deprive them of the means to acquire knowledge. As Socrates said in Plato’s Symposium, women do not lack intellect or a natural disposition to succeed in every understanding and every kind of learning equally to men." (99)
 
In advocating for equal education, Tarabotti first establishes that intelligence is not an intrinsic quality. She argues that all learned men became intelligent only through receiving an education: “All philosophers and men of learning have gained their knowledge by studying; nobody was ever born with infused wisdom” (97). She references Plato’s Symposium to argue further that both men and women share a similar disposition to learn. In asserting that women share this disposition to learn with men, Tarabotti refutes the argument that women are naturally less intelligent than men and as a result, less worthy of an education. She argues that women do not “lack intellect or a natural disposition to succeed in every understanding and every kind of learning equally to men” (99). Instead, women lack access to the kind of education that make men intelligent. 

Tarabotti highlights the way men inhibit women from receiving a proper education. She describes the hypocrisy of men who “while reproaching women for stupidity…strive with all [their] power to bring them up and educate them as if they were witless and insensitive” (99). Tarabotti criticizes men who treat women as if they were naturally less intelligent and use this prejudice as reason for providing women with inadequate education or no education at all: “[Men] give [women] as a governess another woman, also unlettered, who can barely instruct them in the rudiments of readings, to say nothing of anything to do with philosophy, law, and theology. In short, they learn nothing but the ABC, and even this is poorly taught” (99). Tarabotti argues that even when a woman does receive an education, she receives her instruction from another uneducated woman. This cycle ensures that all women remain less intelligent than men. Thus, Tarabotti reframes the issue of women’s observed lesser intelligence as stemming from a man-made system and not from the nature of women themselves.

​​Further, even when women attempt to teach themselves, men stifle their ambitions and redirect them to “‘feminine’ tasks like needlework and spinning” (99). Tarabotti argues that when men “catch sight of a woman with pen in hand,” they “order them under penalty of death to put aside their scribbling” (99). To support her argument that women should be able to pursue a range of activities, Tarabotti compares her native Italy to other countries like “France, Germany, and many northern provinces” in which women have “liberty” (100). In these countries, “women perform public roles,” “handle money, and keep accounts of merchandise” (100). These women “make use of that free will granted by the Giver of all good things” (100). In contrast, women in Italy “grow accustomed” to “constraints and insults” and are not able to exercise their God-given free will (100). They are “like some unfortunate bird shut up- rather, buried- in intolerable confinement” (100).  Tarabotti underlines the lives of women in other countries to show that the extent of the capability of a woman is highly contingent on the context in which they find themselves. 
Picture

​Throughout “Book Two,” Tarabotti establishes intelligence as an attribute only available to those who receive proper education and exposes men for creating a system of inadequate education for women so that they may maintain their power. 
 --MP

​
Source info: Paternal Tyranny. Edited and translated by Letizia Panizza. The University of Chicago Press, 2004. 
Image info: Standing Woman Holding a Scroll. Artist unknown. Italy, 16th century. 
Source: https://artvee.com/dl/standing-woman-holding-a-scroll
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    ​Olivia Branscum is a PhD student in Philosophy at Columbia University. She is co-producer of the ENN New Voices podcast

    Haley Brennan is a PhD student in Philosophy at Princeton University. She is co-producer of the ENN New Voices podcast

    ​
    Matheus Mazzochi is an undergraduate Philosophy major at Simon Fraser University. His posts are signed MM.

    Mary Purcell is an MA student at Simon Fraser University. Her posts are signed MP.

    Archives

    December 2022
    October 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021

    Categories

    All
    16th Century Women
    17th Century Women
    18th Century Women
    19th Century Women
    Abolitionism
    Ada Lovelace
    Aesthetics
    Africana Philosophy
    American Women Philosophers
    Andean Philosophy
    Angela Foligno
    Animal Rights
    Anna Julia Cooper
    Anti Oppression
    Anti-oppression
    Anti Slavery
    Arcangela Tarabotti
    Attention
    Audre Lorde
    Beauty
    Black Women Philosophers
    Brazilian Women
    Canadian Women Philosophers
    Catherine Of Siena
    Claudia Jones
    Contemplative Tradtion
    Decolonization
    Early 20th Century Women
    Education
    Edward Blyden
    Emile Du Chatelet
    English Women
    Environmental Ethics
    Equality
    Eternity
    Feminism
    Frances Power Cobbe
    Frederick Douglass
    Free Will
    French Women
    Germaine De Staël
    German Women
    Hadewijch
    Harriet Martineau
    Hildegard Von Bingen
    Idealism
    Identity
    Indigenous Peoples
    Indigenous Philosophy
    Intersectionality
    Italian Women
    Julian Of Norwich
    Karoline Von Günderrode
    Labour Movements
    Language
    Laura Bassi
    Lorraine Hansberry
    Love
    Lucrezia Marinelli
    Margaret Ebner
    Maria Stewart
    Marriage
    Mary Ann Shadd Cary
    Medieval Women
    Metaphysics
    Mind And Body
    Moderata Fonte
    Moral Education
    Natural Philosophy
    Nísia Floresta
    Phenomenology
    Phillis Wheatley
    Philosophy Of Mind
    Philosophy Of Science
    Podcast
    Political Philosophy
    Public Philosophy
    Research Methods
    Rosa Luxemburg
    Sexuality
    Simone De Beauvoir
    Simon Weil
    Sor Juana Inés De La Cruz
    Venetian Women
    Veronica Franco
    Virtue
    W.E.B Du Bois
    Wisdom
    Women's Rights

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • About
    • Project Description
    • Team
    • Postdoctoral Fellows >
      • 2023-24 Post-Doc Ad
    • Governance
    • New Narratives PDG (2015-19)
  • Building Resources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Digital >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliography of Works by Early Modern Women Philosophers
      • Digital Collections
      • Multimedia >
        • Podcast
    • Print
  • Developing Research
    • Conferences
    • Seminars
    • Workshops
    • Works-in-Progress Seminars
    • Reading Groups
    • ENN Blog
    • Other Events
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Media Mentions
    • Publications
  • Related projects
    • Columbia Center for New Narratives in Philosophy
    • In Parenthesis Project
    • Querelle
    • Archeology of the Female Intellectual Identity (AFII)
    • Brazilian Network of Women in Philosophy
    • Center for the History of Women Philosophers and Scientists
    • Histories of philosophy in a Global Perspective
  • Acceuil
  • À Propos
    • Description du projet
    • Chercheurs postdoctoraux, chercheuses postdoctorales >
      • 2023-24 Appel Post-Doc
    • Équipe
    • Direction
  • Construire des ressources
    • ENN Collaborator Publications
    • Ressources numériques >
      • Project Vox
      • Bibliographie d’œuvres de femmes philosophes du passé
      • Collections numériques
      • Multimédia
    • Ressources papier
  • Développer la recherche
    • Conférences FR
    • Workshops FR
    • Séminaires de travaux en cours
    • Groupes de lecture
    • D'Autres Évènements
  • Nouvelles
    • Annonces
  • Projets liés